Topics
More on Quality and Safety

P4P maintains quality of care, study finds

Pay-for-performance (P4P) does not cause a negative impact on patient outcomes, according to a new study.

The study was released by researchers from the American College of Surgeons (ACS) at the ACS Clinical Congress in San Francisco on Thursday.

The researchers said they studied 1,768 patient cases for eight different types of major operations, including gastric bypass and lung procedures.

[See also: P4P may 'divert' healthcare from those who need it the most.]

According to the researchers, they investigated data from databases kept by the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (ACS NSQIP) and the Society of Thoracic Surgeons on surgeries that were performed at three New York City hospitals from 2007 through 2010.

The investigators found that complications and death rates did not change appreciably after pay-for-performance programs were initiated, reported lead investigator Faiz Bhora, MD, associate program director, general surgery program, St. Lukes-Roosevelt Hospital Center. 

Some stakeholders have been concerned that pay-for-performance programs will cause physicians to avoid treating sicker, frailer patients in order to make their outcomes look better. Bhora said this study found no evidence of that. 

“Our case mix index was no different before or after pay for performance; there was no evidence of cherry picking of cases,” he said. Bhora said this is one of the first studies of pay for performance that has looked at patient outcomes.

[See also: P4P could hurt poor, minorities.]

The ACS research team said quality care outcomes should be the essential framework for pay-for-performance programs. “There’s always a concern that incentive programs may affect the quality of care,” Bhora said. That’s where we as physicians need to stay engaged with pay-for-performance programs, so that it’s not just a financial program, but a quality program as well.”

Follow Diana Manos on Twitter @DManos_IT_News.